Thursday 9 May 2013

Songwriting - A New and Fascinating Experience

Last week I completed another Coursera course, so of course I should write a blog post about it. The course I completed was called Songwriting. When I first saw the course listing on the Coursera website I thought "That looks interesting, why don't I give it a go? It's free after all.", so I signed up and waited for it to start.

Before I go into a more in-depth discussion of the course (as seems to be my MO with these blog posts now) I will say that I never considered myself to be creative, or at least not creative in the way that a songwriter is creative. Yet, having completed this course I was very surprised at how easy it was to come up with lyrics for songs, especially for the week 5 assignment, where we had to write our first full song. So, with that said, here is an overview of what I did for each week of the 6-week course.

Week 1 - The Journey of a Song

The first week of the course gave an introduction to the course and what we would be expected to achieve by the end. We then moved into the course proper. The focus was on the idea of a song, introducing the idea of prosody - having all the elements of the song come to together to tell the same story. The video lectures talked about song forms, identifying the point of view of the song, the development engine, and introduced the boxes for creating the idea of a song. The peer review assignment for the end of the first week was to take one of the supplied song titles (or a title of our own) and, using the boxes, describe the point of view of the song and how it would move through the boxes, showing how the title would gain more meaning as it passes through each box.

This was a nice gentle start to the assignments and didn't just drop you in the deep end by having you write lyrics from week 1. This easy(ish) start made the course seem a lot less daunting than it did before I started.

Week 2 - Stopping and Going

In the next week we looked more at prosody and the ideas of stability and instability in a song. This idea was fascinating and since doing the course it has made me appreciate the music I listen to so much more, where I now can sometimes notice where stability and instability have been used to emphasise a part of a song. This week looked at how the number of lines and the lengths of lines within a song can create stability and instability.

The end of week assignment involved us writing some lyrics for the first time. We had to write an unstable verse and a stable chorus, using the number of lines and line lengths to create the stability and instability. I took what I had learned and wrote my first ever verse and chorus and was quite pleased with it. My peers seemed to like it too and I got a modest grade for it. Completing the first assignment that involved actually writing lyrics gave me a lot of confidence to continue with the course and I was looking forward to each assignment, although I was always doubting that I'd be able to complete them.

Week 3 - Sonic GPS—Mapping Your Song with Rhyme

Now we were building up quite a few tools for the creation of our songs, with the next important tool being rhyme. The video lectures went through all the different sorts of rhymes and how each type helped to create stability or instability. Once again, the lessons were fascinating and gave a great insight into rhyme that, being a beginner to this sort of thing, was something I hadn't realised. I thought that there were only perfect rhymes and you couldn't rhyme words like 'bent' and 'mend', but you can, they are just different sorts of rhymes and they help to create different ideas in your songs.

The week 3 assignment was similar to the week 2 assignment, except this time we had to write a stable verse and an unstable chorus, using all the things we had learnt so far, including rhymes. Again, I gave it a good go and got a reasonable grade for it in the peer review, along with some useful feedback.

Week 4 - Making it Move

So far, most of the lessons have looked at the lyrics alone without really involving any music. That was to change in week 4. Now we were looking at how the lyrics match up with the beat and rhythm of the music. We learnt about stressed syllables within our lines, and how these should be matched to the stressed beats in the music. We also learnt about how you can play with these ideas to make the song "move" - creating motion and momentum in your song so the listener feels like they are going on a journey.

The assignment for this week was what I was looking forward to least. The assignment was to take our verse and chorus from the week 3 assignment and to record ourselves speaking the lyrics along to a musical loop, making sure we placed the stressed syllables on the stressed beats. I was not looking forward to this because I really don't like hearing my voice or recording my voice, let alone letting anyone else hear it. But, with some encouragement from my wonderful fiance and some time alone in the house so nobody could hear me do it, I completed the assignment. Once again, I got some useful feedback and a pretty good grade for it. We were getting closer to writing our own song and I still didn't think I'd be able to do it.

Week 5 - Writing the Song

So, here it was, time to write our first ever song. The tutor helped us through this process by taking us through his process to write a new song of his own, so he was effectively writing a song with us. The biggest things introduced during this week were the use of melody and the use of a song worksheet.

The use of melody was the hardest part of the course for me to get my head around. I'm not a very musical person and a lot of the talk of stable and unstable notes went over my head. Thankfully, my fiance is a lot more musical than I am so helped me out with the melody for what would become my first ever song.

The worksheet though, was invaluable to me being able to complete the week 5 assignment in time. The assignment involved writing and performing a complete song (we didn't have to create music for it, there were many musical loops provided that we could perform the song over, which is what I did). The worksheet was used to create a list of keywords for the song and, using a rhyming dictionary, to create lists of words that rhymed (different types of rhymes) with each keyword. This gave me a nice long list of words to use and gave me lots of inspiration for how the song would progress.

My completed worksheet for The End of Cold
My completed worksheet, showing the keywords and rhymes I found.

Once the song had been written (it took me about 3 days to write the worksheet and lyrics) it was time to add the melody and record it. As mentioned, I had a lot of help from my fiance creating the melody for the song but that wasn't all. She is (in my opinion) a great singer and so much better than me, with bags more confidence when it comes to recording herself, so after asking really nicely, she agreed to sing the song for me for the assignment. I should point out that the assignment states that it is a songwriting course, not a singing course, so the quality of singing doesn't matter, but I had no confidence that I'd be able to do it and didn't want to drop out of the course because of it. Anyway, she recorded the song for me and it sounded pretty good. I was very happy with it and I submitted it. The song was called "The End of Cold" and was a journey through the seasons to find love.

I was very nervous waiting for the peer reviews for this assignment; it was my first ever song and I had no idea what people would think of it. In the end I needn't have worried, I got a really good grade for it and some really nice comments from my peers, in particular this one (the marking is anonymous so there is no name attached to the comment):

"Yeah! The line end of cold has a neat melody. The lyrics are great! Epic actually. Frickin' Epic! I would like to hear it with music designed for you specifically. I like the lyrics a lot! You are a good writer! Nice!"
That comment in particular made me feel really good about what I'd managed after just 5 weeks of this course.

Week 6 - Crossing the Finished Line

This final week of the course looked at how to work on the song to improve it, keeping in mind the idea of prosody. The video lectures focussed on a song that had been written and looked at how things could be changed to create a much better song. We looked at what front-heavy and back-heavy lines are and how they can used to add meaning to your song. Using these ideas we then had to work on our song from the week 5 assignment and make changes to it to improve it. As I was quite happy with my song from week 5 I only made a few minor changes to the song and got my fiance to re-record it for me. Thankfully, my week 5 grade was not a fluke and I got another really good grade for it and some more really nice feedback comments from my peers.

My lyrics as a work in progress
A shot of my lyric sheet with various notes showing the changes it went through from the first draft.

Final Thoughts

I very much enjoyed this course, considering it to be one of my favourite courses that I've completed on Coursera. The tutor had an excellent presence on the videos and felt perfectly at ease talking to a camera. This made the course a lot more engaging and kept my interest better than for some other courses I have taken part in. the quizzes were good at checking our knowledge and, although they said at the start of the course that we would need to have a list of songs that would be looked at during the course, they were all available on YouTube in some way so access to all of the songs looked at was possible. The assignments were very well structured, starting off easy and gradually building up to writing a full song. Doing this really did help to build up my confidence to be able to write a whole song by the end of the course.

During the peer reviews, I had to review a number of assignments that were submitted by people who had previous songwriting and performing experience, so there seemed to be a wide range of experience levels taking the course. This didn't detract from the course, although I did occasionally find it difficult to give useful feedback to those peers that clearly had substantially more experience than me.

Overall, I would very strongly recommend this course to anyone, particularly those with no experience of songwriting and who had never thought of writing songs before and who want to try something new. I had a blast taking this course and honestly surprised myself with how well I did in the end. I didn't think I would finish the course with a score of 88.3%, that's for sure.

And finally, with very kind permission of my fiance (you are amazing, my love, I love you and can't wait to marry you), you can listen to my week 6 assignment song here. I have also posted the lyrics of the song below so you can follow along and join in if you like. Feel free to let me know what you think of it in the comments below.


The End of Cold

Gazing out, over my kingdom
From this throne,
Of ice and snow,
Looking for something of distinction
To break this land of dark unknown,
Of white extinction
Determined to withhold
The end of cold?

Out of the mist, Nature's first bloom
You grab my hand, dragged from this gloom.
Together forward,
Stumbling, awkward,
Messy, disordered.
Swept up in the rush, riding a flume,
Towards our pot of gold,
The end of cold.

Light in the tunnel
Keep moving on
Light in the tunnel
Don't want to stumble.

Now sitting together, facing the sun
Looking ahead, it's gonna be fun
Basking in joy, each other we've found
Once icy land, now our playground
What a sight to behold,
The end of cold.
The end of cold.

Wednesday 20 February 2013

The Long and Winding Udacity Road...

For a change, I'm not going to talk about my most recently completed Coursera course. Unfortunately, a long Christmas break and moving house (with the accompanying troubles of getting an internet connection sorted out) resulted in me falling behind on two Coursera courses I was taking part in so I regretfully un-enrolled from them both. I shall maybe write about those dropped courses and the reasons why they were dropped in another post.

This post is specifically about Udacity, another MOOC website that I was made aware of. Here are some of my thoughts on the site and what makes it different to my other experiences (Coursera), why I signed up, and what I think of it having now completed one of their courses.

What's It All About?

Really, rather than me try to explain Udacity's philosophy, mission statement, future plans, etc, it would be better if you go and check it out for yourself, here.

I have not been signed up to the site for long and have not experienced everything they have to offer but from what I've seen they offer a number of online courses (all free) mainly focussed on computing and mathematics. The courses are split into three levels: beginner, intermediate and advanced. This allows you to get an idea of how difficult each course will be for you and also allows you to guage whether you are challenging yourself with the course you have chosen.

The structure of the courses is similar to the courses I have studied with Coursera; that is, video lectures with quiz questions mixed in followed by homework exercises at the end of each unit. They also have a final exam at the end of the course that works in the same way as the homework exercises. Once a course has been completed you can download a certificate of completion for the course (a nice feeling when you can print something out to show your accomplishment).

How is it Different from Coursera?

Although both sites use a similar structure to the courses, there are some big differences between the two. Firstly, Coursera courses are run at specific times, much like a course in an institution, with a start and end date and the units being released to students on a weekly basis. Udacity, on the other hand, makes all of the units available from the start and leaves it up to the student to study them at their own pace. Personally, I like this approach as it means you don't have to try and find a set time commitment each week to complete the week's unit. If you happen to have a busy few weeks you won't fall behind with Udacity because you just carry on when you are ready. This was particularly useful in the last few months because of the problems with moving house mentioned above. I didn't need to drop my Udacity course because there was no time limit for completion.

The platform used by Udacity for delivering the courses also appears to be different to Coursera's, with videos being posted on YouTube and embedded in the site's UI. Despite the videos being hosted on YouTube, the Udacity team are still able to incorporate quiz questions within these videos by taking screenshots of the videos and creating a quiz page from that between videos.

The site is very clean and well presented. This year they updated the look of the site and made a lot of very good improvements to the UI, which makes it even nicer to use the site.

So, Why Did I Sign Up?

Well, I have said in the past that I like computing and programming, so when I saw the courses they had to offer I got very excited. The choices were amazing, I liked the look of pretty much all of the courses on offer, at every skill level. Because they all looked and sounded so interesting I decided to commit myself to attempt to complete every course they have to offer on the site. This may turn out to be an impossible task but I'm going to give it my best shot, so I started by signing up to the beginner's course 'Introduction to Computer Science'.

The aim of the course was to teach computer science and Python programming by working towards building a search engine. It was the thought of building a search engine that really caught my eye. When I signed up for it I had just started a Python programming course on Coursera so I was going to be learning Python twice but in the end I feel like I learned more because of the different way each site taught things and the order they were taught in. As it turns out, building a search engine isn't as daunting a task as it first appears. It seems the hardest part of the process is coming up with a name for your search engine (any suggestions?).

The videos were very well presented and the tutors were all very good at talking to camera and giving lectures. The quizzes and homework made sure that all of the units were understood, and the use of 'starred' questions (questions that are harder than the regular homework questions) were a great opportunity to push your skills and demonstrate how much you had learned. Some of the starred questions were very, very hard but completing them (sometimes after several days of trying) felt like such a great achievement I would surprise whoever happened to be sat near me at the time as I suddenly punch the air in excitement.

The site also has a very good discussion forum that is well organised with tags for questions so you can find relevant posts to whichever unit you happen to be working on at the time. I didn't post in the forums at all but I did find a lot of inspiration and help from the answers to other peoples' questions.

Final Thought

I really like Udacity. I like the way you can do the courses at your own pace, the huge selection of courses available at each skill level (as long as you want to focus on computing) and I like the way the courses are delivered. Although the challenge I have set myself - to complete every course they offer - seems daunting and damn near impossible, I look forward to giving it a go. One course down so far, and the next course up is 'Introduction to Physics' :)